| vs Graham Canwell |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 24 - 17 | (SD)[SB] | | |
| |
| | |
| (PS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | (PS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | |
| | |
| ( PS pts : Dave Carruthers 24 , Graham Canwell 17 ) | |
| Back to table |
| vs Stuart Clayton |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 23 - 7 | (MD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 23 , Stuart Clayton 7 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Ian Currie |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Chiefs | 28 - 23 | (KC) | | | Chargers | 35 - 31 | (SD) | | | Chiefs | 28 - 14 | (KC)[WC] | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 30 - 24 | (KC) | | | Chiefs | 14 - 3 | (SD) | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 38 - 0 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 24 - 19 | (KC) | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Chargers | 17 - 10 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 42 - 16 | (KC) | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 32 - 7 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 29 - 23 | (KC) | OT | |
| 2002 [SD] | Chargers | 35 - 14 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 27 - 0 | (KC) | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Chargers | 34 - 3 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 42 - 11 | (KC) | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 58 - 10 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 31 - 28 | (KC) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 14 - 2 | | (RS) Home Record : 7 - 1 | | (RS) Away Record : 7 - 1 |
| (PS) : Ian Currie leads series, 1 - 0 | | | (PS) Away Record : 0 - 1 |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 500 , Ian Currie 238 ) | |
| ( PS pts : Ian Currie 28 , Dave Carruthers 14 ) | |
| Back to table |
| vs Alan Dadswell |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 28 - 20 | (SD) | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 34 - 14 | (TT) | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Titans | 27 - 10 | (TT) | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 30 - 17 | (SD) | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Titans | 16 - 10 | (TT) | OT | |
| 2003 [SD] | Chargers | 30 - 9 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 4 - 2 | | (RS) Home Record : 3 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 2 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 142 , Alan Dadswell 103 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Troy Dilworth |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Chargers | 27 - 16 | (SD) | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Steelers | 27 - 17 | (PS) | | | Steelers | 16 - 0 | (SD)[WC] | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Steelers | 28 - 17 | (PS) | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Chargers | 16 - 7 | (SD) | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Steelers | 27 - 17 | (PS) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Troy Dilworth leads series, 3 - 2 | | (RS) Home Record : 2 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 0 - 3 |
| (PS) : Troy Dilworth leads series, 1 - 0 | | (PS) Home Record : 0 - 1 | |
| ( RS pts : Troy Dilworth 105 , Dave Carruthers 94 ) | |
| ( PS pts : Troy Dilworth 16 , Dave Carruthers 0 ) | |
| Back to table |
| vs Mark Dixon |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 41 - 22 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 41 , Mark Dixon 22 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Darren Drew |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Chargers | 23 - 13 | (BB) | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 51 - 3 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 2 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 74 , Darren Drew 16 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Simon Fotheringham |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Chargers | 34 - 10 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 34 , Simon Fotheringham 10 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Mark Gamble |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 17 - 9 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 17 , Mark Gamble 9 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Paul Gregory |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 44 - 14 | (CI) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 44 , Paul Gregory 14 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Stuart Guard |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 20 - 7 | (MD) | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Chargers | 18 - 7 | (SD) | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 23 - 17 | (SD) | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Chargers | 38 - 35 | (MD) | OT | |
| 2003 [SD] | Dolphins | 23 - 10 | (MD) | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 33 - 27 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 5 - 1 | | (RS) Home Record : 3 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 2 - 1 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 142 , Stuart Guard 116 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Glenn Havenhand |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 34 - 31 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 37 - 7 | (SD)[CC] | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Chargers | 21 - 14 | (CL) | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 24 - 14 | (CL) | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Chargers | 24 - 3 | (CL) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 4 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 3 - 0 |
| (PS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | (PS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 103 , Glenn Havenhand 62 ) | |
| ( PS pts : Dave Carruthers 37 , Glenn Havenhand 7 ) | |
| Back to table |
| vs Jon Heath |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Eagles | 38 - 31 | (PE) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Jon Heath leads series, 1 - 0 | | | (RS) Away Record : 0 - 1 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Jon Heath 38 , Dave Carruthers 31 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Bruce Henderson |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Bears | 14 - 3 | (CB) | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Chargers | 20 - 0 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Series tied, 1 - 1 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 0 - 1 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 23 , Bruce Henderson 14 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Neil Henderson |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Chargers | 38 - 20 | (OR) | | | Chargers | 24 - 3 | (SD) | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 34 - 14 | (OR) | | | Chargers | 34 - 10 | (SD) | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 30 - 7 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 39 - 31 | (OR) | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Chargers | 51 - 10 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 27 - 13 | (OR) | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Chargers | 40 - 7 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 16 - 8 | (OR) | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 31 - 9 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 34 - 18 | (OR) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 12 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 6 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 6 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 398 , Neil Henderson 150 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Julian Horne |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Chargers | 24 - 13 | (CL) | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Browns | 33 - 17 | (CL) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Series tied, 1 - 1 | | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 1 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Julian Horne 46 , Dave Carruthers 41 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Stuart MacKinnon |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Chargers | 28 - 9 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 29 - 0 | (OR) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 2 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 57 , Stuart MacKinnon 9 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Paul Muldoon |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Browns | 35 - 17 | (CL) | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 34 - 7 | (CL) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Series tied, 1 - 1 | | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 1 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 51 , Paul Muldoon 42 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Richard Ogg |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 34 - 3 | (SD) | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Chargers | 45 - 30 | (BB) | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 19 - 17 | (SD) | OT | | Bills | 38 - 13 | (BB)[DC] | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Bills | 32 - 10 | (BB) | | | Bills | 19 - 13 | (SD)[DC] | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Chargers | 24 - 14 | (SD) | | | Bills | 20 - 14 | (BB)[DC] | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Bills | 35 - 20 | (BB) | | | Bills | 40 - 18 | (BB)[DC] | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 4 - 2 | | (RS) Home Record : 3 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 2 |
| (PS) : Richard Ogg leads series, 4 - 0 | | (PS) Home Record : 0 - 1 | | (PS) Away Record : 0 - 3 |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 152 , Richard Ogg 131 ) | |
| ( PS pts : Richard Ogg 117 , Dave Carruthers 58 ) | |
| Back to table |
| vs Stephen Parratt |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 51 - 11 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 51 , Stephen Parratt 11 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Terry Purrington |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Jets | 35 - 28 | (SD) | | | Jets | 27 - 10 | (SD)[WC] | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Jets | 45 - 6 | (NY) | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Chargers | 16 - 14 | (SD) | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Jets | 24 - 20 | (SD) | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 23 - 17 | (NY) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Terry Purrington leads series, 3 - 2 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 2 | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 1 |
| (PS) : Terry Purrington leads series, 1 - 0 | | (PS) Home Record : 0 - 1 | |
| ( RS pts : Terry Purrington 135 , Dave Carruthers 93 ) | |
| ( PS pts : Terry Purrington 27 , Dave Carruthers 10 ) | |
| Back to table |
| vs Pat Ratcliffe |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Chargers | 13 - 0 | (SD) | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Chargers | 56 - 21 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 2 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 2 - 0 | |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 69 , Pat Ratcliffe 21 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Peter Seymour |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Bengals | 41 - 7 | (CI) | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Bengals | 28 - 21 | (SD) | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 17 - 10 | (SD) | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Chargers | 12 - 6 | (SD) | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Bengals | 17 - 14 | (SD) | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Chargers | 24 - 21 | (SD) | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Chargers | 31 - 29 | (CI) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 4 - 3 | | (RS) Home Record : 3 - 2 | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 1 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Peter Seymour 152 , Dave Carruthers 126 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs C.J. Sheehan |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Chargers | 21 - 6 | (DL) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 21 , C.J. Sheehan 6 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Neil Shepherd |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 21 - 6 | (GB) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 21 , Neil Shepherd 6 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Owen Shepherd |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Chargers | 10 - 3 | (SD) | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 29 - 6 | (NY) | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 20 - 10 | (NY) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 3 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 2 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 59 , Owen Shepherd 19 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Paul Spence |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Redskins | 30 - 13 | (SD) | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 21 - 17 | (SD) | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 10 - 6 | (SD) | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Redskins | 21 - 3 | (WR) | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Redskins | 31 - 7 | (WR) | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Redskins | 31 - 14 | (WR) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Paul Spence leads series, 4 - 2 | | (RS) Home Record : 2 - 1 | | (RS) Away Record : 0 - 3 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Paul Spence 136 , Dave Carruthers 68 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Andy Starkey |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 41 - 25 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 41 , Andy Starkey 25 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Keith Stevens |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 21 - 19 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 21 , Keith Stevens 19 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Derek Tottle |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Seahawks | 37 - 7 | (SS) | | | Seahawks | 24 - 7 | (SD) | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 21 - 17 | (SS) | | | Seahawks | 24 - 3 | (SD) | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 24 - 10 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 14 - 0 | (SS) | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Seahawks | 24 - 10 | (SS) | | | Seahawks | 35 - 18 | (SD) | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 37 - 14 | (SD) | | | Seahawks | 31 - 28 | (SS) | OT | |
| 2002 [SD] | Chargers | 31 - 7 | (SS) | | | Chargers | 14 - 6 | (SD) | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Seahawks | 21 - 17 | (SS) | | | Seahawks | 37 - 7 | (SD) | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Chargers | 21 - 19 | (SS) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Derek Tottle leads series, 8 - 7 | | (RS) Home Record : 3 - 4 | | (RS) Away Record : 4 - 4 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Derek Tottle 306 , Dave Carruthers 259 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Gerald Udowiczenko |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1997 [SD] | Chargers | 10 - 3 | (NE) | | |
| 1998 [SD] | Chargers | 23 - 13 | (SD) | | |
| 1999 [SD] | Chargers | 29 - 7 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 23 - 10 | (SD)[DC] | | |
| 2000 [SD] | Chargers | 35 - 7 | (NE) | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 25 - 14 | (NE) | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Chargers | 9 - 6 | (SD) | OT | |
| 2003 [SD] | Chargers | 14 - 10 | (NE) | | |
| 2004 [SD] | Patriots | 34 - 31 | (SD) | OT | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 7 - 1 | | (RS) Home Record : 3 - 1 | | (RS) Away Record : 4 - 0 |
| (PS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | (PS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 176 , Gerald Udowiczenko 94 ) | |
| ( PS pts : Dave Carruthers 23 , Gerald Udowiczenko 10 ) | |
| Back to table |
| vs Tim Whitfield |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2002 [SD] | Vikings | 23 - 13 | (SD) | | |
| 2003 [SD] | Chargers | 22 - 9 | (SD) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Series tied, 1 - 1 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 1 | |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 35 , Tim Whitfield 32 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Lewis Williams |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 38 - 0 | (SD) | | | Chargers | 23 - 9 | (OR) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 2 - 0 | | (RS) Home Record : 1 - 0 | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 61 , Lewis Williams 9 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |
| vs Neil Young |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 2001 [SD] | Chargers | 10 - 3 | (CB) | | |
| |
| (RS) : Dave Carruthers leads series, 1 - 0 | | | (RS) Away Record : 1 - 0 |
| | |
| ( RS pts : Dave Carruthers 10 , Neil Young 3 ) | |
| | |
| Back to table |